Ciceros Pizza

Reviews

• Samantha F.

  star star star star star 30 May 2026

  This is hands down my favorite pizza place in the area. Service is fantastic! It's not a California healthy pizza, but it is absolutely delicious.
  
  Free Parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes with every order.
  
  Call ahead for pickup.

• Lisa C.

  star star star star star_border 29 May 2026

  My favorite pizza joint in the area! Cicero's has a long history and only one location, which makes it special and something you can't get anywhere else. They also only sell thin crust pizza, which is a plus for me because I prefer a thin crust over a thick crust.
  
  I live close to Cicero's so I always call beforehand to order and then pick up. It's super easy and convenient.
  
  My go-to order is always the medium Belly Buster, with the olives substituted for jalapeños (no extra charge). It's so good! The pizza is also pretty filling even though it's a thin crust. They're very generous with the toppings. In my opinion the medium pizza could feed 2 people.
  
  I ordered the small pizza before but it's NOT worth it. It's way too small, even for one person. Do yourself a favor and split a medium pizza with someone.
  
  The only reason why Cicero's isn't 5 stars for me is because the pizzas are expensive. I grew up with Cicero's and I remember the prices being around $17 a few years ago for a medium Belly Buster. Now it's $19.25. It's more expensive than other pizza joints but also it's a unique place you can't find anywhere else. Even though the prices are high I will definitely come back :)

• Shilpa J.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 24 May 2026

  I don't know what's happening at Cicero's but pizza quality has been declining steadily. On 8/6 I got large pizza and instead of a thin crust we got a pretty thick crust pie.
  
  I called and some weird woman answered claiming to be a manager. Apparently owner and manager were on vacation. ??!! Kept saying that dough rises if we pick the pizza late. What?! I picked it up within 20 min and I have never heard such bizarre claims to begin with.

• Kawaii S.

  star star star star star_border 22 May 2026

  Ordered to go and picked up and they promise! And yay..... pizza are ready.
  As usual their pizza is always good and beyond regular, but more in the pricy side - pay for the quality and services
  This placed is always packed on the weekend, in complex of Safeway and parking was super easy with big lot.
  
  Good place to hang out with friends and having a good pizza!
  
  You nailed it!

• Ingrid G.

  star star star star star 14 May 2026

  After all these year still get 2 large pizzas every week!.  Cicero's please never leave me